TRANSPORTATION

Judge bars Uber from using key tech for driverless autos

Associated Press

DETROIT — A federal judge’s order that bars Uber from using technology taken by a star engineer before he left Waymo is bad news for Uber and likely will hurt the ride-hailing company’s own self-driving research, according to legal experts.

The ruling by District Judge William Alsup in San Francisco on Monday was mainly a victory for Waymo, the autonomous car unit spun off from Google, even though the judge refused to order a halt to Uber’s autonomous car research as Waymo had requested, the experts said.

Waymo showed “compelling evidence” that a former Waymo engineer named Anthony Levandowski downloaded thousands of confidential files before leaving the company, the order said. Levandowski set up his own firms, which then were sold to Uber for $680 million. Evidence showed that Levandowski and Uber planned the acquisitions before Levandowski left Waymo, Alsup’s order said.

“He clearly believes that Levandowski is guilty as sin and that Uber hired him, knowing this full well,” said John Coffee, a Columbia University law professor who specializes in white-collar crime and corporate governance. “He is ruling that some of this information is stolen (or ‘misappropriated’) and in the long run that will likely have a devastating impact on Uber.”

Waymo sued Uber in February alleging that the ride-hailing company is using stolen self-driving technology to build its own autonomous cars.

Monday’s ruling prevents Uber from using the technology on a laser navigational tool called Lidar that robotic cars use to see what’s around them.

“The bottom line is the evidence indicates that Uber hired Levandowski even though it knew or should have known that he possessed over 14,000 con›idential Waymo files,” Alsup wrote. “At least some information from those files, if not the files themselves, has seeped into Uber’s own Lidar development efforts.” Uber was ordered to return all downloaded materials to Waymo by noon May 31.

Alsup ordered Uber to remove Levandowski from any role in Lidar, and that it stop him from copying or otherwise using the downloaded materials.

Waymo had sought to shut down Uber’s autonomous car program until the dispute is settled. But Alsup determined that Waymo’s patent infringement theories were too weak to support such an order. The judge ruled that although it’s hard to imagine that Levandowski “plundered Waymo’s vault the way he did” with no intent to use the material, Waymo still fell short of showing that the trade secrets were used.

Uber said in a statement Monday that it’s pleased the court allowed it to continue the research, including its own Lidar innovations. “We look forward to moving toward trial and continuing to demonstrate that our technology has been built independently from the ground up,” the statement said.

Waymo, which is part of Google parent Alphabet Inc., said it welcomed the order stopping Uber from using “stolen documents containing trade secrets.”

The ruling, coupled with Alsup’s order last week referring the case to federal prosecutors, signals that Alsup is leaning toward Waymo based on evidence thus far, said Carl Tobias, a law professor at the University of Richmond. “I think it’s pretty clear that he sees it for the plaintiffs as opposed to defendants,” Tobias said.

The high-stakes corporate espionage case now will proceed to evidence exchanges between both sides and will go to trial if not settled, Tobias said..

The ruling will hamper Uber’s ability to develop a self-driving car more quickly than Waymo, Coffee said, but it’s too early to say if Uber will be crippled by the ruling.